The Public Sector HealthCare Roundtable joined 59 employer, patient, labor, and purchaser organizations in signing a letter led by the Coalition Against Surprise Medical Billing to the Departments of Treasury, Labor, and Health and Human Services raising concerns about the implementation of the Independent Dispute Resolution (IDR) process under the No Surprises Act (NSA). The coalition emphasized that while the NSA was designed to protect patients from surprise medical bills and promote fair negotiations between providers and health plans, the current operation of the IDR process is increasingly driving higher costs for patients, employers, and plan sponsors.
Recent analyses cited in the letter estimate that the IDR process generated at least $5 billion in additional spending between 2022 and 2024, largely driven by a high volume of disputes filed by a small number of provider organizations. In the first half of 2024, four provider groups accounted for 74 percent of all IDR cases, often submitting charges averaging 370 percent of Medicare rates for the same services. Providers have also prevailed in a majority of arbitration decisions, with median awards in provider-won disputes exceeding four times the qualifying payment amount (QPA), the market-based benchmark intended to guide arbitration decisions.
The coalition urged the Departments to strengthen guardrails around the IDR process to ensure it functions as intended. Recommended actions include clarifying arbiter guidance around the use of market benchmarks, increasing transparency into arbitration determinations, and strengthening oversight of certified IDR entities. Signatories emphasized that the IDR process should remain a narrow backstop for resolving true surprise billing disputes, rather than becoming a routine mechanism for setting prices that could undermine the affordability of employer-sponsored coverage.
